 |
HBOT
in Strokes
Stroke is a neurological deficit resulting
from interruption of blood supply to the
brain. It is one of the leading causes of
death and disability and remains one of
the diseases most resistant to treatment.
The most common type is thrombotic stroke
where a blood clot forms in a major artery
due to disease of the artery. This is very
similar to myocardial infarction, also known
as a heart attack. Less common types of
stroke include embolic stroke where a blood
clot travels from the heart or a major artery
to lodge in a brain artery and hemorrhagic
stroke where a cerebral artery ruptures
and bleeds. Since the entire body and brain
are under vascular pressure from the arterial
side (mean blood pressure about 90) to the
venous side (mean pressure about 0) interruption
of blood supply creates a low pressure zone
at the center of the blood deprived area.
The brain is not equipped with alternate
large arteries that can immediately supply
fresh blood to a damaged area so the injured
brain must depend on blood trickling in
from the tiny peripheral capillaries. As
this blood proceeds to the center of the
stroked region it passes down a pressure
and oxygen gradient with each successive
millimeter of brain extracting more oxygen.
The resulting brain pathology is one of
concentric shells of brain tissue of different
degrees of oxygenation. These different
levels of oxygenation determine different
levels of brain cell function. This description
of the stroke lesion is the classic umbra/penumbra
model (35). The umbra
represents the most oxygen depleted core
of the lesion that dies. The penumbra is
the outer shell which consists of injured
potentially salvageable brain tissue (see
diagram right).
|
|
The most important question in stroke
is how long can the umbra and penumbra survive
before blood flow and oxygen are reestablished.
Medical dogma through 1989 rigidly assumed
that 6 minutes was the maximum time before
the umbra died and possibly 30-60 minutes
for the penumbra. In 1990 Dr. Neubauer published
the "Idling Neuron" (21)
letter to the editor of The Lancet that
shattered the existing dogma by showing
with SPECT brain imaging and hyperbaric
oxygen therapy survival of the penumbra
for 14 years in a 60 year old stroke victim.
That patient recovered partial neurological
function with a combination of hyperbaric
and normobaric oxygen therapy delivered
over a course of about one year, 14 years
after her severe stroke. While this case
is unusual other cases exist in the medical
literature and Dr. Harch's hyperbaric experience.
Unfortunately, there is no foolproof method
to determine the amount of penumbra that
is still recoverable days to years after
stroke. SPECT brain imaging is one possibility
when performed before and after a single
hyperbaric treatment (see case below), but
often a trial course of HBOT is the only
method.
HBOT for acute and chronic stroke is based
on Henry's Law which states that the amount
of a gas, e.g. oxygen, that is dissolved
in a liquid solution, e.g. blood, is proportional
to the pressure of the gas interfacing with
that solution. Since nearly 98-99% of hemoglobin
in blood is saturated with oxygen at sea
level all additional oxygen added by hyperbaric
oxygen exposure is dissolved in the liquid
plasma portion of the blood. It is this
dissolved oxygen that exerts its drug effect
on the pathology and pathophysiology in
stroke and the other neuropathologies described
on this website. In the history of hyperbaric
medicine over 30 animal studies and 25-30
human studies have been published on HBOT
in stroke. The best review of these is in
Chapter 17 of the Textbook of Hyperbaric
Medicine by K. K. Jain, 3rd Edition, 1999.
The data is overwhelmingly positive in the
animal studies and mostly positive in the
human studies, but the human trials have
lacked rigor. This discrepancy was the impetus
for the newly launched HOTFAST (Hyperbaric
Oxygen Therapy For Acute Stroke) Trial which
commences in the Fall of 2000 at a number
of centers in the United States. The project
consists of three phases that will span
5-10 years if funded (see
the end of this website): a first phase
to assess feasibility and safety, a second
phase to evaluate the proper dose, and a
third phase to assess effectiveness. Coordination
of the study is through the National Stroke
Research Center in Winston-Salem, North
Carolina and the Department of Biostatistics
at the University of Alabama, Birmingham
with Drs. James F. Toole and Paul G. Harch
as the principal investigators and Dr. Richard
Neubauer as the senior honorary consultant.
While some studies are underway in chronic
stroke increasing data is accumulating that
is strongly suggesting that chronic stroke
may be treatable with HBOT. Such a case
from Dr. Harch's practice is presented below.
Case Presentation:
The patient is a 68 year old male complaining
of persistent light-headedness since his
third stroke nearly two years ago. The dizziness
was of such severity that his balance and
gait were affected and the patient became
housebound and cane dependent. In addition
he had weakness in his left leg, hyperextension
problems with the left knee, trouble controlling
his left arm, and incoordination on his
right side. MRI of the brain showed multiple
white matter strokes. SPECT brain imaging
was performed before and after a single
low-pressure HBOT and is displayed in Figures
1 and 2. The images are transverse with
the first scan on the left and the second
scan on the right of each figure and proceed
from the top to the base of the brain. Note
the global increase in brain blood flow
(more yellow), increased smoothness and
symmetry, and increased flow to the right
cerebellum and temporal lobe (third,
fourth, and fifth rows of Figure 2).
On the basis of this change and the patient's
subjective improvement he underwent a course
of low-pressure HBOT and experienced marked
reduction of his dizziness, improved ability
to walk without a leg brace and cane, better
balance and coordination, and notable improvement
in his previously depressed mood. Repeat
SPECT brain imaging reflected these gains
as shown in Figures 3
and 4 which are side by side comparisons
of the first scan to his final scan. The
changes first noted in the second scan after
a single HBOT (above) are now reproduced
in the final scan and felt to be more permanent.
Three dimensional reconstructions of all
three scans are shown in Figures
5, 6, and 7 in the frontal face view.
Note the generalized improvement in the
surface of the brain and the dramatic increase
in flow to the patient's right temporal
lobe and cerebellum.
Click Image to Enlarge
|

|

|
|
Figure 1
|
Figure 2
|
|
|

|

|
|
Figure 3
|
Figure 4
|
|
|
|
Click Image to Enlarge
|

|

|

|
Figure 5
|
Figure 6
|
Figure 7
|
|
|
21. Neubauer RA, et al. Enhancing "idling"
neurons. Lancet, 1990;335:542.
35. Astrup J, Simon L (1981) Thresholds
in cerebral ischemia -- The ischemic penumbra.
Stroke 12:6, 723-725.
|
|
|
 |